So, I've read all the wikis. I tried setting up SMTP email settings and I'm still unable to get the New Ticket Alert to function. To clarify, the diagnostic email works, the assign user works, the respond to email works, all of it, EXCEPT for new ticket alert. All of the settings are correctly set and none of the New Ticket Alert settings are set to DISABLED.
I asked the developer to upgrade us to 1.9.5.1. I will see what happens after that, unless anyone has any further trouble shooting to offer me first?